Mystery of the Abbey / Similar games

18 games like Mystery of the Abbey

The best games like Mystery of the Abbey are Orient Express, Scripts & Scribes and Shadows over Camelot — the closest of 18 ranked alternatives, scored by shared mechanics and category. Orient Express shares deduction, murder/mystery, area movement with Mystery of the Abbey.

Every alternative below links to its own Mystery of the Abbey-style fact page, drawn from MeeplePick’s deduction / medieval shelf.

Ranked by shared category (3 pts) and mechanics (2 pts), bonus within 0.7 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 2.2 weight, then BoardGameGeek’s Bayesian rating — one entry per series, 18 shown.

As an Amazon Associate, MeeplePick earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

1. 1. Orient Express (1985)
   1–6 players · 60 min · ★ 6.7 · Medium-light
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Murder/Mystery, Area Movement, Dice Rolling, Events, Paper-and-Pencil · 4 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (67%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · plays solo · ~15 min shorter · same complexity
   View Orient Express on Amazon →
2. 2. Scripts & Scribes (2007)
   2–4 players · 30 min · ★ 7.2 · Medium-light · games like Scripts & Scribes →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Religious, Hand Management, Set Collection · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · goes down to 2 · ~45 min shorter · 0.5 lighter
   View Scripts & Scribes on Amazon →
3. 3. Shadows over Camelot (2005)
   3–7 players · 60–80 min · ★ 7.1 · Medium · games like Shadows over Camelot →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Medieval, Dice Rolling, Hand Management · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · scales to 7 · about the same length · +0.4 heavier
   View Shadows over Camelot on Amazon →
4. 4. Deception Murder in Hong Kong (2014)
   4–12 players · 20 min · ★ 7.5 · Medium-light · games like Deception Murder in Hong Kong →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Murder/Mystery, Events · 1 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (17%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 4–6 players · scales to 12 · ~55 min shorter · 0.6 lighter
5. 5. Discworld Ankh-Morpork (2011)
   2–4 players · 60 min · ★ 7.2 · Medium-light · games like Discworld Ankh-Morpork →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Dice Rolling, Events, Hand Management · 3 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (50%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · goes down to 2 · ~15 min shorter · same complexity
6. 6. Raiders of the North Sea (2015)
   2–4 players · 60–80 min · ★ 7.8 · Medium · games like Raiders of the North Sea →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Dice Rolling, Hand Management · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · goes down to 2 · about the same length · +0.3 heavier
7. 7. Awkward Guests (2016)
   1–8 players · 45–75 min · ★ 7.7 · Medium-light · games like Awkward Guests →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Murder/Mystery, Hand Management · 1 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (17%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · plays solo · scales to 8 · ~15 min shorter · same complexity
8. 8. Battle Line Medieval (2017)
   2 players · 30 min · ★ 7.7 · Medium-light
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Medieval, Hand Management, Set Collection · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: no player-count overlap (2–2 vs 3–6) · goes down to 2 · ~45 min shorter · 0.3 lighter
9. 9. Champions of Midgard (2015)
   2–4 players · 60–90 min · ★ 7.8 · Medium · games like Champions of Midgard →
   Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Dice Rolling, Set Collection · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
   vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · goes down to 2 · about the same length · +0.4 heavier
10. 10. Police Precinct (2013)
    1–6 players · 90 min · ★ 6.9 · Medium
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Murder/Mystery, Dice Rolling, Hand Management · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · plays solo · ~15 min longer · +0.3 heavier
11. 11. Mysterium (2015)
    2–7 players · 42 min · ★ 7.3 · Medium-light · games like Mysterium →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Murder/Mystery, Hand Management · 1 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (17%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · goes down to 2 · scales to 7 · ~33 min shorter · 0.3 lighter
12. 12. The Pillars of the Earth (2006)
    2–4 players · 90–120 min · ★ 7.3 · Medium · games like The Pillars of the Earth →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Religious, Events · 1 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (17%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · goes down to 2 · ~30 min longer · +0.6 heavier
13. 13. Nuns on the Run (2010)
    2–8 players · 45 min · ★ 6.5 · Medium-light · games like Nuns on the Run →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Religious, Dice Rolling, Paper-and-Pencil · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · goes down to 2 · scales to 8 · ~30 min shorter · same complexity
14. 14. Citadels Classic (2000)
    2–8 players · 20–60 min · ★ 7.1 · Medium-light · games like Citadels Classic →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Deduction, Medieval, Set Collection · 1 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (17%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–6 players · goes down to 2 · scales to 8 · ~35 min shorter · 0.2 lighter
15. 15. The Road to Canterbury (2011)
    2–3 players · 60 min · ★ 6.9 · Medium-light
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Religious, Hand Management, Set Collection · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: both play at 3 · goes down to 2 · ~15 min shorter · same complexity
16. 16. The Cities and Knights of Catan (1998)
    3–4 players · 90 min · ★ 7.5 · Medium · games like The Cities and Knights of Catan →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Dice Rolling, Hand Management · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · ~15 min longer · +0.7 heavier
17. 17. Tainted Grail The Fall of Avalon (2019)
    1–4 players · 60–120 min · ★ 8.3 · Medium · games like Tainted Grail The Fall of Avalon →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Area Movement, Dice Rolling, Hand Management · 3 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (50%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · plays solo · ~15 min longer · +1.1 heavier
18. 18. Samurai (1998)
    2–4 players · 30–60 min · ★ 7.5 · Medium-light · games like Samurai →
    Shares with Mystery of the Abbey: Medieval, Hand Management, Set Collection · 2 of Mystery of the Abbey’s 6 mechanics (33%)
    vs Mystery of the Abbey: overlaps at 3–4 players · goes down to 2 · ~30 min shorter · +0.3 heavier

Looking for the original? See the full Mystery of the Abbey fact page — players, play time, age and complexity.